Everybody Wants the Throne. Nobody Wants the Cross.
Submitted by: Darla Burton
Patriarchy and Feminism. There was a time, not all that long ago, when I could have defined these two words rather simply. Nowadays, however, that is no longer quite such an easy feat. What ought to have been a fairly straightforward distinction has become an increasingly complicated ideological battleground, and I am beginning to wonder whether we have become so preoccupied with defending our respective positions that we have forgotten what we were arguing about in the first place.
Patriarchy, in certain circles, appears to have evolved into something more closely resembling a tyrannical regime than the garden-variety misogyny we have become accustomed to witnessing. It would appear, simply regarding women as inferior was not quite sufficient. We needed an entire theological framework to justify keeping them there.
Feminism, on the other hand, well, I am not entirely sure where to begin, much less where to end. And yes, I am perfectly aware that the opposite of patriarchy is matriarchy. Thank you for the vocabulary lesson we can now consider unnecessary. But that is not the cultural and theological tug-of-war I am addressing here.
The first wave of feminism, generally traced to the women's rights convention held in Seneca Falls, New York, in 1848, was championed by women such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Lucretia Mott, and later by Susan B. Anthony, Sojourner Truth, and countless others. These women challenged the rather astonishing notion that they should be denied fundamental rights simply because they had the audacity to be born female.
The battleground was not particularly difficult to understand. Women were fighting for legal recognition, property rights, educational opportunities, political representation, and the apparently outrageous privilege of being treated as fully-fledged human beings. And judging by certain modern-day Christian fundamentalist circles entertaining the idea of repealing the 19th Amendment and stripping American women of their voting rights, it would seem that the mere suggestion of a woman's equal value and dignity remains an atrocious insult to some men's masculinity.
Heaven forbid a woman should enter the workforce, own property, exercise her own judgment, or, God help us all, cast a vote. Apparently, the prospect of a woman possessing a mind of her own was enough to threaten the very foundations of manhood. And what a remarkably fragile foundation that must have been if the mere recognition of a woman's humanity threatened to reduce its most prized masculine assets to the size of peanuts. No pun intended. Well, perhaps just a little.
Oh, who am I kidding?
When Ownership Masquerades as Leadership
According to some of today's self-appointed patriarchs, it would seem we have been terribly misguided in believing that women were created for anything other than serving men. The world belongs to the boys, and the rest of us should be sufficiently grateful that they've graciously permitted us to occupy a little space in it. What makes this arrangement particularly audacious is the rather convenient umbrella of biblical manhood beneath which these claims are being promoted.
For generations, many women did not question the authority men claimed over them. Men were generally bigger,
physically stronger, and occupied positions of institutional and legal power. Women, quite frankly, were rarely
afforded the same advantages. And when physical strength, economic dependence, religious authority, and
the threat of consequences are employed to secure someone's obedience, we ought to possess enough
common sense to recognise coercion when it is staring us squarely in the face.
Of course, a generous sprinkling of theological seasoning seems to work wonders on the arrangement. Coercion
becomes submission, domination becomes leadership, and the man demanding obedience is miraculously
awarded the title of servant leader. How remarkably convenient.
I would, however, like to point out something that ought not require a theological degree to comprehend. When one
human being claims ownership over another, we already have a word for that. It is called slavery. And no amount
of biblical vocabulary, appeals to divine design, or creative interpretations of headship will magically transform the
possession of another human being into servant leadership.
Feminism: Apparently, We Need a New Dictionary
Even so, historically, women were not fighting to become men. Why on earth would we? We were fighting for the right to exist as women without being treated as though our sex constituted some unfortunate deficiency in our humanity.
Which brings me to feminism as we know it today, and good heavens, what an extraordinary assortment of interpretations we've managed to accumulate under one little word. The definition appears to change depending on the platform, the particular woman claiming the title, or the self-appointed defender of patriarchy explaining to the rest of us what feminists supposedly believe. Between the increasingly elaborate labels and the rather imaginative portrayals circulated by those determined to make women's independence sound like an impending threat to civilization, I am not entirely convinced I could keep up with it all if I gave it my darnedest effort.
And so, what exactly is feminism?
Well, if you are asking me, I would have thought the answer was relatively straightforward. At its most basic, feminism advocates for equality between women and men. And when I say equality, I am not referring to sameness. I am referring to equal dignity, equal opportunity, equal treatment under the law, and equal compensation for equal work. That is the understanding of feminism I am working with, and I intend to stick with it. Anyone wishing to attach an additional seventeen ideological amendments to the definition is certainly welcome to do so, but I shall respectfully decline the invitation to accompany them down that particular rabbit hole.
I do not need to become a man to be considered equally human, nor should a man need to surrender
his masculinity to acknowledge that I am.
Now, what does either patriarchy or feminism have to do with the gospel of Christ? Well, as ideological platforms,
absolutely nothing. Not a blessed thing. And therein lies my point.
Somewhere between the creation of humanity and our rather creative interpretations of what it means to be the
body of Christ, we apparently decided that one body wasn't quite sufficient. So we divided it into camps, assigned
everyone a label, and proceeded to argue over which half was entitled to run the show. Being united in Christ was
all well and good, it seems, provided we could first establish who was in charge.
Genesis 3:16: When a Consequence Became a Commandment
The irony of Genesis 3:16 is certainly not lost on me. In the aftermath of the Fall, God announces the consequences of humanity's disobedience, including the rather unfortunate development that “he will rule over you,” alongside
the declaration that the woman's desire will be for her husband.
Now, I am not about to drag us into an exhaustive theological examination of the Hebrew nuances surrounding the word desire. That particular conversation could occupy an entire essay of its own, and I have no intention of adding another seventeen pages of linguistic debate to our itinerary today. Nevertheless, whatever interpretation we arrive at, the introduction of domination into the relationship between man and woman was hardly something to celebrate. And I would venture to suggest that women have had rather good reason to object to it ever since.
And this is where the absurdity really outdoes itself. God Himself announces this fractured relationship in the
context of humanity's separation from Him. It is part of the tragic consequences of the Fall, not a congratulatory
address to Adam on his promotion to management.
Yet here we are, thousands of years later, attempting to baptise the very consequences of sin in holy water, grant them an honorary doctorate in biblical authority, and convince everyone that God was not describing the damage at all. He was issuing a divine decree that the fractured relationship between male and female was to be faithfully preserved, preferably with the woman sufficiently grateful for her newly diminished standing.
I do wonder whether anyone has considered the rather inconvenient possibility that we are defending the very condition from which we profess to have been redeemed. But I suppose redemption is a minor detail when there is a hierarchy to preserve. God's intention for humanity was declared at creation. We need not rummage through centuries of cultural traditions, ecclesiastical arrangements, or somebody's rather enthusiastic interpretation of male authority to discover it. Genesis 1:26–28 introduces humanity as male and female, both created in the image of God, both blessed, and both entrusted with dominion over creation. There is no announcement of a hierarchy between them, no allocation of superior status based on reproductive anatomy, and certainly no indication that one was appointed to supervise the other's existence.
Now, if you intend to trumpet primogeniture as your rebuttal, I am afraid I shall have to disappoint you. I have already addressed that particular argument in my writing, and my book, The Tangent Series: Tearing the Veil, takes a considerably deeper dive into the subject for anyone interested in examining the rather extraordinary proposition that arriving first automatically qualifies someone to be in charge. This essay is not about primogeniture, and I refuse to spend the afternoon chasing Adam around the Garden to determine whether being fashioned from dust a little earlier entitled him to issue instructions to everyone who arrived after him.
What this essay is about, however, is the absolute monstrosity of a mess we have made of the Scriptures and the
division we have manufactured within the body of Christ. We have turned the very passages intended to inform
our understanding of God and our relationships with one another into ammunition for defending our respective ideologies.
The really astonishing part is that we seem perfectly content to keep pulling the trigger while professing allegiance
to the very Christ who called us to be one.
In Genesis 2:24, we are introduced to another rather inconvenient detail. Husband and wife are joined together as one flesh, a union that makes no mention of competing positions of authority, superior status, or the rather peculiar notion that one half of this union was appointed to govern the other. Those are God's words, not mine. Take it up with Him.
Nowhere, absolutely nowhere, does God announce that women have forfeited their equal standing as His image-bearers. Yet, judging by some of the arguments circulating in Christian circles, one might reasonably conclude that He had issued a subsequent amendment revoking women's original status and transferring their share of humanity's God-given authority to men. I must have missed that particular announcement.
In the beginning, male and female existed as counterparts, sharing in the goodness of God's creation, living together without shame, without the hostility that would follow the Fall, and enjoying unhindered fellowship with their Creator. They were naked, for heaven's sake, and neither had thought to appoint themselves the other's spiritual supervisor. It is rather remarkable how much authority we have managed to manufacture out of a relationship that God originally described as very good.
And when that unhindered fellowship with God was fractured, so too was the harmony between male and female. That is what God announced. That is what humanity has been suffering through ever since, along with the rather extensive catalogue of other consequences we inherited from the Fall. But the consequences of sin did not erase the image of God in either of His children. Humanity's relationship with its Creator was fractured, not its identity as His image-bearers.
We are living in the aftermath of a seismic rupture, yet, for reasons I find increasingly difficult to comprehend, certain proponents of patriarchy seem determined to convince us that the resulting fractures are evidence of God's
intended arrangement. And so, to those who incessantly declare that God established a hierarchy of authority
within marriage, I have a rather straightforward question. Where?
Where, precisely, does God announce that the woman, created equally in His image and joined to her husband as one
flesh, has been assigned a subordinate position beneath him? And please, spare me the lengthy detour through
cultural customs, assumptions about birth order, and the astonishing number of conclusions we have managed to
extract from what Scripture does not actually say.
How, exactly, does one divide one flesh?
Let me spell this out in elementary language, since we have managed to complicate something that ought not
require an advanced degree in theology to comprehend. With humanity's relationship to the Father now fractured,
His children began fighting like cats and dogs over who was entitled to the bigger piece of the pie.
Naturally, the bigger sibling decided he ought to have the whole bakery.
Now, I would imagine most parents would be rather pleased if their children could manage to coexist without one attempting to establish a dictatorship over the other. But convincing your sister that Dad secretly appointed you head of the household, particularly when He had already given you both an inheritance, is a rather creative interpretation of the family arrangements.
But alas, the serpent continues to strike at the woman's heel, and the hostility announced in the Garden has found itself a rather comfortable home among God's sons and daughters. One might even suspect that the enmity has acquired a few enthusiastic volunteers. Now, where have we seen this particular brand of hostility taking up residence? Oh, I know. Patriarchy!
Perhaps someone ought to write God a Pauline-style letter informing Him that the boys have developed a rather creative understanding of their inheritance and are refusing to share with their sisters. It seems a formal reprimand may be in order, although I suspect they would insist on reviewing the letter for theological accuracy before permitting anyone to deliver it.
Although, on second thought, perhaps we should reconsider the letter. I can already imagine someone extracting a
sentence from it, removing it from its context, and constructing an entire doctrine explaining why the girls were never
entitled to read the correspondence in the first place.
It would seem patriarchy is rather dead set on resurrecting the Fall, proudly defending the very fracture that Christ came to heal, while insisting that doing so is an act of faithfulness to Him. Meanwhile, reminding your brother that you are both children of the same Father is treated as an attempted hostile takeover of the family estate.
We are no longer discussing which sibling gets the bigger share of the inheritance. We are confronting the audacity of one sibling insisting that the other was never entitled to sit at the Father's table in the first place. Identity is what is at stake here, and patriarchy, it would seem, is still taking prisoners.
When the Father's Name Becomes the Alibi
Do we actually comprehend the magnitude of what is taking place here? We are talking about a human life. A daughter
who has been told that her Father, the very One who lovingly formed her in His image, deliberately created her to be less
than her brother. Not by accident, nor as a consequence of humanity's rebellion, but intentionally, as though her
inferior standing was part of His original intention for her existence. She is expected to believe that her subordinate
position was His idea, that the limitations imposed upon her are an expression of His love, and that she ought to be
eternally grateful for the privilege of knowing her place.
And what, precisely, do we imagine that does to a daughter's heart? Listen here, we are telling God's daughters that their Father deliberately created them with a deficiency in their very souls, an emptiness where His unconditional love
and affirmation ought to reside. That they were fashioned not as fully valued human beings with their own identities,
purposes, and relationship with Him, but as creatures bred for the benefit of another, their worth measured by
their usefulness and their obedience.
It is a grotesque picture, one that bears a disturbing resemblance to a breeding mill, where the value of a living creature is determined not by the sacredness of its existence but by what can be extracted from it. And to suggest that the Father Himself designed His daughters for such an existence, then expected them to thank Him for the privilege, is an accusation against His character that ought to horrify anyone claiming to know His heart.
What happens when a woman begins to believe that the Father she is commanded to love is the very One responsible for her humiliation? When she comes to understand her own existence as something He deliberately diminished, her gifts as something He deliberately restricted, and her voice as something He never particularly wanted to hear?
And notice how conveniently this arrangement reduces a grown woman to the status of a child, perpetually requiring supervision, correction, and permission from someone supposedly better equipped to determine what is good for her. She may possess decades of wisdom, experience, spiritual maturity, and an intimate relationship with her Creator, but none of that appears sufficient to earn her the right to be treated as a fully capable adult. Be seen, not heard. Know your place.
We are not merely talking about the subordination of women. We are talking about the systematic poisoning of a daughter's relationship with her Father, carried out by those who claim to speak on His behalf. And when that daughter begins to recoil from the God she has been taught to fear rather than trust, the very people responsible for distorting His character have the audacity to accuse her of bitterness, disobedience, and rebellion. And should she remain unconvinced by their rather generous interpretation of God's intentions for her existence, there is always the added incentive of eternal damnation, with a place in the fiery furnace of hell supposedly reserved for those who dare question the arrangement. Now, remind me, where have we encountered this hostility toward the woman before? Ah, yes. The Garden.
The serpent was told there would be enmity between him and the woman, and between his offspring and hers. And here we are, thousands of years later, watching certain proponents of patriarchy hoist the flag of enmity with all the enthusiasm of soldiers marching into battle, seemingly oblivious to whose banner they may be carrying.
I can almost picture the serpent reclining in an expensive leather armchair, a glass of Jack Daniel's on ice in one hand and a rather extravagant cigar in the other, watching the spectacle unfold with the smug satisfaction of someone who has discovered that he no longer needs to dirty his own hands. Why bother convincing a daughter to mistrust her Father when someone standing behind a pulpit will do it for him? Why spend another afternoon sowing division when the children have become so proficient at tearing one another apart, all while insisting that their Father specifically instructed them to do so?
He needn't even leave his chair. The enmity is being preached, defended, institutionalised, and passed down to the next generation, accompanied, rather extraordinarily, by the assurance that this is what God intended all along. And the most grotesque irony of it all is that those perpetuating the hostility may genuinely believe they are defending the Father's honour, while the daughters He created are being taught to despise the very nature of the God whose image they bear.
The serpent, it would seem, has played his hand well. Very, very well indeed.
We see the consequences of male entitlement and domination splashed across headlines with depressing regularity.
But some of their most disturbing expressions do not announce themselves with clenched fists or raised voices.
Sometimes they sing hymns on Sunday morning, greet you with a pleasant smile, and might even recite a Bible
verse for you, provided you have been sufficiently well behaved. And if you haven't, there is always a passage
conveniently available to remind you of your place.
And the voices are getting louder, the platforms are getting bigger, and the audiences are growing. The message
is being delivered with an increasingly brazen confidence that ought to alarm anyone who professes to
care about the integrity of the Gospel.
We have men publicly promoting the subordination of women, presenting their authority over their wives as a divine entitlement, and treating a woman's independence as though it were an infectious disease threatening to bring civilization to its knees. They are broadcasting these convictions, preaching them, publishing them, and encouraging other men to embrace them as evidence of biblical masculinity.
Meanwhile, the women subjected to these teachings are expected to receive them with gratitude, demonstrate their obedience with enthusiasm, and refrain from making everyone uncomfortable by mentioning the consequences. And should one of them have the nerve to object, there is always someone prepared to explain that her resistance is precisely why women ought not be trusted with authority in the first place.
What an extraordinarily efficient little arrangement. The accusation supplies its own evidence, the accused is denied the authority to challenge it, and the person making the accusation gets to congratulate himself on having defended the Word of God. All in a good day's work.
When the Guilty Become the Judges
And while we are discussing rebellion, I would dearly love to know how women managed to become its unofficial poster children when Adam himself provides us with such an impressive demonstration of the behaviour. Let us not forget
what Scripture actually says. According to 1 Timothy 2:14, Adam was not deceived. Romans 5:12 and 5:19 go so far as
to place the entrance of sin and the disobedience through which humanity suffered squarely at Adam's feet. And
when God confronted him in Genesis 3:12, did our courageous representative of biblical manhood stand before his
Creator and accept responsibility for his actions? Not on your life. He pointed at the woman. And for good
measure, he implicated God Himself for having given her to him.
Now, consider the breathtaking audacity of what we have done with that account. Adam has somehow become the preferred exhibit in the case for male spiritual authority, while Eve's deception has been paraded through centuries of theological argument as evidence that her entire sex requires male supervision. By this extraordinary line of reasoning, Adam's deliberate disobedience qualifies him for leadership, while Eve's deception disqualifies her descendants from exercising it. And then we have the gall to accuse women of rebellion when they question the arrangement.
I would suggest that before anyone delivers another sermon about the dangers of rebellious women, they might
consider the rather damning testimony of the man whose behaviour they seem so determined to excuse. And
given the seemingly endless procession of so-called “moral failings” among those entrusted with spiritual
authority, I do wonder how much more evidence we require before abandoning the rather extraordinary assumption
that being male is somehow a qualification for moral superiority.
Now, I am no psychologist, but there is something rather familiar about accusing another person of the very behaviour one is unwilling to confront in oneself. Projection, I believe, is the term. If you think this rather convenient reversal of responsibility was confined to the Garden, allow me to introduce you to one of its particularly ugly modern-day relatives: a phenomenon frequently described as reactive abuse, although I would argue that the terminology itself deserves to be hauled in for questioning. A woman can endure years of intimidation, humiliation, deception, manipulation, and coercive control, but the moment she finally raises her voice, confronts the behaviour, or establishes a boundary that inconveniences the person benefiting from her silence, suddenly we have ourselves a problem. It would seem we have become so proficient at assigning blame that we have forgotten the rather elementary distinction between causing harm and responding to it.
Not with the conduct that brought her to this point, mind you. That can wait. We have a woman's reaction to investigate.
And should she become angry, well, heaven help us. Now she is contentious, disrespectful, unsubmissive,
emotionally unstable, or, everyone's personal favourite, rebellious. And let us not forget the reviling wife, whose
refusal to quietly accommodate her husband's conduct can become the subject of yet another sermon on the
dangers of women who will not submit to male authority.
What an interesting contrast. We have an entire Christian literary genre devoted to every man's battle, complete with explanations of temptation, struggles, setbacks, and the need for grace. But when a woman begins responding to the consequences of those battles, her distress can be repackaged as evidence that she is the real problem. His behaviour is a battle to be understood. Hers is a character defect to be corrected. The original wrongdoing has barely managed to find its way into the conversation before her response has been hauled before the disciplinary committee.
And then, for the grand finale, we introduce the therapeutic language of mutual responsibility. Both parties contributed to the problem, we are told, and therefore both must examine their behaviour and accept responsibility for their respective contributions. What a wonderfully civilized conclusion, particularly for the person who has spent years creating the very conditions now being presented as a mutual disagreement.
If you mistreat someone long enough to provoke a reaction, you can eventually use that reaction as evidence that the two of you are equally responsible for the mess. And should a counsellor, pastor, or well-meaning mediator fail to distinguish between the pattern of abuse and the response to it, the very system entrusted with addressing the harm can become another instrument through which it is perpetuated.
We have now managed to make the injured person responsible not only for surviving the wrongdoing, but also for ensuring that her response does not inconvenience the person who caused it. The system protects itself, the harm continues, and everyone gets to congratulate themselves on having successfully addressed the conflict. How terribly convenient.
What's that I smell? Ah, yes. The serpent's cigar. The smoke is getting rather thick in here, and judging by the circumstances, I suspect he's taken up chain-smoking. The show has become far too entertaining to put the thing down.
God's Sons Are Not the Enemy
For those sharpening their pencils to accuse me of being a man-hating feminist, allow me to save you the trouble. I am not a misandrist, although I suspect that particular accusation will find its way into the conversation regardless of what I have written. A woman can spend an entire essay defending the dignity of human beings and still find herself accused of despising approximately half of them.
I love men. I love my husband. I love my father. I love my uncles. I love my cousins. I love my brothers in Christ. I have two absolutely wonderful sons-in-law, and I have grandsons whose futures matter enormously to me. I want these men,
and every other son of God, to know the true heart of their Father, to understand the sacredness of their own existence,
and to recognize the profound responsibility that comes with bearing His image.
I do not want a world without men. I do not want a church without men. I certainly do not want my grandsons growing up in a society that regards their masculinity as some unfortunate defect requiring an apology for their existence. And I will be equally uncompromising about any ideology that attempts to convince them that being male automatically makes them an oppressor, a threat, or an expendable member of humanity. What an appalling inheritance to hand a child.
Equally, I do not want these boys inheriting a version of Christianity that teaches them their worth is measured by how successfully they exercise authority over women. I do not want them confusing physical strength with moral superiority, mistaking entitlement for leadership, or believing that their sisters must become smaller in order for them to become men. What kind of Father would want His sons to derive their identity from the diminishment of His daughters?
And what does it say about the Gospel we are handing the next generation when we can no longer distinguish between the strength required to protect another human being and the cowardice involved in controlling one?
Patriarchy, when it becomes a system of male entitlement and domination, does not merely rob women of their identity. It robs men of something profoundly precious as well. It distorts their understanding of what it means to bear the image of God and risks alienating them from the very heart of the Father they profess to represent.
Imagine being taught that your God-given masculinity entitles you to something Christ Himself never demanded from
those He came to save. Imagine reaching adulthood convinced that the measure of your faithfulness is the degree to
which someone else submits to your authority, rather than the degree to which your own life reflects the character
of your Saviour. What a rather unfortunate misunderstanding of the very Saviour whose name you have been
invoking to defend the arrangement.
Men are not the enemy of women, and women are not the enemy of men. Neither is an inferior edition of humanity, nor was either created as an unnecessary accessory to the other's existence. We are not interchangeable, we are not disposable, and we most certainly are not competing for the right to bear an image that God has already bestowed upon us both.
I want my grandsons to grow into men whose strength is governed by love, whose convictions are informed by Scripture, whose courage is demonstrated through integrity, and whose understanding of masculinity bears some recognisable resemblance to the Christ they profess to follow. I want them to know their Father, not merely the version of Him that someone has constructed to secure a preferred arrangement of power. Teaching God's sons that their identity depends upon the subordination of His daughters does not elevate manhood. It makes their worth dependent upon the humiliation of another human being, and I cannot think of a more pitiful understanding of what it means to be a man.
One New Humanity. Apparently, That Was Too Much to Ask.
I have a question. When exactly did we decide that the Gospel of Jesus Christ needed to become a battleground upon which men and women were commissioned to fight one another? Are we in Rome? Is this the Colosseum? Have we assembled the gladiators, divided the spectators into opposing camps, and decided that the last one standing gets to claim victory on behalf of Christ? I would dearly love to know where Jesus issued the invitation to this particular blood sport.
Consider Ephesians 2:14–16. Paul is addressing the hostility that separated Jews and Gentiles, two groups whose religious, cultural, and historical divisions were hardly insignificant. And what does he announce? That Christ has made them one, destroyed the dividing wall of hostility, and reconciled them to God through the cross, creating in Himself one new humanity.
Yes, I am perfectly aware that Paul was addressing Jews and Gentiles rather than men and women, so we can dispense
with the theological dissertation on the historical context. In fact, I would encourage you to keep reading, because that
very context makes the argument for reconciliation all the more compelling. If Christ reconciled those who had
been separated by centuries of religious and cultural hostility, on what conceivable grounds do we imagine that
His body ought to cultivate hostility between its male and female members?
If that application still makes anyone uncomfortable, we can turn to Galatians 3:28, where Paul explicitly identifies male and female among those who are one in Christ Jesus. One in Christ does not mean identical, interchangeable, or stripped of our individuality, our distinctions, or the remarkable diversity with which our Creator endowed humanity. We do not cease to be male or female any more than we cease to possess the individual gifts, abilities, and personalities that make us who we are.
And then we have 1 Corinthians 12, where Paul describes the church as one body composed of many members, each belonging to the whole and contributing to its functioning. Paul does not describe a body in which certain members are permitted to declare the others unnecessary, nor does he suggest that one member's significance depends upon another's diminished standing. In fact, he goes to considerable lengths to explain precisely the opposite.
A Servant Washes Feet. He Does Not Whip People With the Towel.
Now, perhaps we ought to revisit the inconvenient example of Jesus Christ Himself, since He does happen to be the central figure in this entire conversation. I realise that bringing His actual conduct into a debate about Christian authority may prove somewhat disruptive to the established arrangements, but I would suggest that anyone claiming to represent Him ought to be prepared to have their understanding of authority measured against His example.
In Mark 10:42–45, Jesus addresses the matter of authority, drawing His disciples' attention to the rulers of the Gentiles who lord their power over those beneath them. Rather than offering His followers a few helpful suggestions for exercising that power more efficiently, He tells them, “Not so with you.” Not so with you.
I wonder how many sermons on biblical authority might require a substantial rewrite if we actually allowed those four words to govern our understanding of Christian leadership. Jesus continues by explaining that whoever wishes to become great must become a servant, and whoever wishes to be first must become a slave of all. He then points to Himself as the example, declaring that even the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give His life as a ransom for many.
And lest anyone imagine that these were merely pleasant philosophical sentiments, John 13 provides a striking
demonstration of what He meant. Jesus, fully aware of His identity and authority, gets up from the table, wraps a towel
around His waist, and begins washing His disciples' feet.
Now, consider the scene. The One whom Christians acknowledge as Lord, the very One through whom all things were made, assumes the position of a servant before the men who follow Him. He does not summon them to the front of the room to demonstrate their submission. He does not demand that they acknowledge His superior position before permitting them the privilege of receiving His attention. He kneels. And when He finishes, He instructs them to follow His example. One would think that such a demonstration might have settled a few questions about the nature of servant leadership, but judging by some of the arrangements being promoted in His name, the significance of the towel appears to have escaped us.
A servant leader washes feet. He does not whip people with the towel.
I cannot imagine how we have managed to turn such an unmistakable demonstration of humility into an arrangement in which one person enjoys the authority and the other is expected to supply the humility. And yet, I have encountered enough explanations of biblical headship to wonder whether we have developed an entirely new definition of servanthood, one in which the person supposedly doing the serving retains the final say, the superior position, and the God-given right to demand obedience from the person being served. What an extraordinary interpretation of washing someone's feet. Apparently, the towel has become a sceptre, and the basin has been replaced with a throne.
Philippians 2:3–8 offers little room for creative reinterpretation. Paul instructs believers to value others above themselves, to look to the interests of others, and to adopt the same mindset as Christ Jesus, who humbled Himself and became obedient to death, even death on a cross. Notice that these instructions are addressed to believers, not merely to women, wives, or some specially designated class of Christians whose biological characteristics qualify them for a lifetime membership in the servanthood department. All of us.
If we are going to invoke Ephesians 5 to defend our understanding of marriage, perhaps we ought to give the instructions directed toward husbands considerably more attention than they ordinarily receive. Husbands are commanded to love their wives as Christ loved the church and gave Himself up for her. Notice that He gave Himself up. He did not demand that the church sacrifice herself to preserve His comfort, protect His reputation, or satisfy His appetite for control. His love was demonstrated through the giving of Himself.
I am not suggesting that Christian leadership is devoid of responsibility or that every exercise of authority constitutes domination. Scripture speaks of leadership, accountability, teaching, and the obligations entrusted to those who
serve others. There is, however, a fundamental difference between accepting responsibility for another person's
welfare and claiming entitlement to govern their existence. One requires humility, integrity, sacrifice, and a willingness
to place the interests of others ahead of one's own. The other requires little more than a convincing explanation
of why someone else ought to obey you.
If your understanding of servant leadership requires another human being to surrender their autonomy, silence their objections, tolerate mistreatment, or relinquish their God-given dignity so that you can maintain your position of authority, you have fundamentally misunderstood what it means to serve. You are not washing their feet. You are standing on their neck, and calling it biblical leadership does not make the weight any less crushing.
Nor does this challenge apply exclusively to men. Women are not exempt from the command to serve, to love sacrificially,
to exercise humility, or to treat others with the dignity owed to those created in God's image. There is no special
dispensation permitting women to become domineering, contemptuous, or cruel merely because they have
experienced injustice, and no version of feminism earns an exemption from Christ's example. The Gospel does not
give us permission to become the very thing we condemn.
We keep asking who gets to be in charge, while Jesus keeps showing us what it means to serve. And if we still cannot recognise the difference, perhaps we ought to put down the towel before we hurt someone else with it. Those things smart, you know, especially when someone has mistaken them for an instrument of correction.
Everybody Wants the Throne. Nobody Wants the Cross.
So here we are, patriarchy and feminism, two words that have become sufficient grounds for launching an ideological war between people who were never intended to be enemies in the first place. I am perfectly capable of distinguishing between feminism's pursuit of equality and patriarchy's claims of authority, thank you very much. Fighting for equal rights is not equivalent to denying them, nor can the historical injustices suffered by women be conveniently erased by declaring that everybody has behaved badly and ought to shake hands.
Any ideology, regardless of its origins or the nobility of its stated intentions, becomes profoundly dangerous when it
begins treating another human being as an obstacle to its own supremacy. I do not particularly care whether the person
doing the diminishing is wearing a suit behind a pulpit or waving a banner in the name of liberation. If your
understanding of human dignity requires someone else's humanity to be reduced, I would suggest that your
definition is in desperate need of re-examination.
The Gospel of Jesus Christ is not an invitation to trade one form of domination for another. We have become so intoxicated with defending our respective positions that I fear we have lost sight of the staggering cost of the reconciliation we profess to celebrate. Why did our Saviour endure humiliation, suffering, and death upon a cross? Why do we gather on Sunday mornings to sing about His sacrifice, proclaim His resurrection, and celebrate the grace through which we have been reconciled to God, only to return to our respective corners and resume the business of tearing apart those He has called us to love?
Do we actually believe the Gospel we are preaching? Or have we become so accustomed to invoking the name of Jesus in defence of our preferred arrangements that we no longer recognise the contradiction between His example and our conduct?
I look at my grandsons and wonder what kind of Christianity they will inherit. Will they encounter a church that teaches them to recognise the image of God in every human being, or one that measures their significance by the degree of authority they can exercise over His daughters? Will they be taught that loving another human being means honouring their dignity, or will they inherit a version of love that confuses devotion with possession?
And what of our daughters? Will they be raised knowing that their Father created them with dignity, purpose, intelligence, and gifts worthy of being exercised in His service? Or will they continue to be handed a theological explanation for why their existence must be negotiated through someone else's authority? I want better for both.
I do not want a world in which women replace men, nor one in which men are elevated at the expense of women. I want a church that has enough reverence for its Creator to stop treating His image-bearers as opposing teams in a competition nobody was commissioned to organise. The impact matters. The people bearing that impact matter. And the integrity of the Gospel we claim to represent matters.
We are not discussing some inconsequential difference of opinion that can be neatly filed away under the
heading of theological disagreement. We are discussing human lives, spiritual identities, damaged relationships, distorted
understandings of God, and generations being taught what it supposedly means to follow Christ. I am increasingly
unwilling to watch that damage be dismissed as the unfortunate but necessary cost of preserving someone's preferred interpretation of biblical authority.
Christ called us to love one another, to serve one another, and to recognize that whatever we do to the least of those among us matters to Him. He did not invite us to construct competing kingdoms in His name, nor did He commission His followers to determine which half of humanity was entitled to occupy the throne. He called us to take up our crosses and follow Him, yet we have become remarkably enthusiastic about defending the authority we believe belongs to us while demonstrating considerably less enthusiasm for the sacrifice He requires of us.
Everybody wants the throne. Nobody wants the cross.
Does your version of patriarchy or feminism uphold the sacredness of the human life God created in His image, or have you become so determined to defend your position that you are prepared to diminish the very people Christ died to redeem?
Submitted by: Darla Burton
Patriarchy and Feminism. There was a time, not all that long ago, when I could have defined these two words rather simply. Nowadays, however, that is no longer quite such an easy feat. What ought to have been a fairly straightforward distinction has become an increasingly complicated ideological battleground, and I am beginning to wonder whether we have become so preoccupied with defending our respective positions that we have forgotten what we were arguing about in the first place.
Patriarchy, in certain circles, appears to have evolved into something more closely resembling a tyrannical regime than the garden-variety misogyny we have become accustomed to witnessing. It would appear, simply regarding women as inferior was not quite sufficient. We needed an entire theological framework to justify keeping them there.
Feminism, on the other hand, well, I am not entirely sure where to begin, much less where to end. And yes, I am perfectly aware that the opposite of patriarchy is matriarchy. Thank you for the vocabulary lesson we can now consider unnecessary. But that is not the cultural and theological tug-of-war I am addressing here.
The first wave of feminism, generally traced to the women's rights convention held in Seneca Falls, New York, in 1848, was championed by women such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Lucretia Mott, and later by Susan B. Anthony, Sojourner Truth, and countless others. These women challenged the rather astonishing notion that they should be denied fundamental rights simply because they had the audacity to be born female.
The battleground was not particularly difficult to understand. Women were fighting for legal recognition, property rights, educational opportunities, political representation, and the apparently outrageous privilege of being treated as fully-fledged human beings. And judging by certain modern-day Christian fundamentalist circles entertaining the idea of repealing the 19th Amendment and stripping American women of their voting rights, it would seem that the mere suggestion of a woman's equal value and dignity remains an atrocious insult to some men's masculinity.
Heaven forbid a woman should enter the workforce, own property, exercise her own judgment, or, God help us all, cast a vote. Apparently, the prospect of a woman possessing a mind of her own was enough to threaten the very foundations of manhood. And what a remarkably fragile foundation that must have been if the mere recognition of a woman's humanity threatened to reduce its most prized masculine assets to the size of peanuts. No pun intended. Well, perhaps just a little.
Oh, who am I kidding?
When Ownership Masquerades as Leadership
According to some of today's self-appointed patriarchs, it would seem we have been terribly misguided in believing that women were created for anything other than serving men. The world belongs to the boys, and the rest of us should be sufficiently grateful that they've graciously permitted us to occupy a little space in it. What makes this arrangement particularly audacious is the rather convenient umbrella of biblical manhood beneath which these claims are being promoted.
For generations, many women did not question the authority men claimed over them. Men were generally bigger,
physically stronger, and occupied positions of institutional and legal power. Women, quite frankly, were rarely
afforded the same advantages. And when physical strength, economic dependence, religious authority, and
the threat of consequences are employed to secure someone's obedience, we ought to possess enough
common sense to recognise coercion when it is staring us squarely in the face.
Of course, a generous sprinkling of theological seasoning seems to work wonders on the arrangement. Coercion
becomes submission, domination becomes leadership, and the man demanding obedience is miraculously
awarded the title of servant leader. How remarkably convenient.
I would, however, like to point out something that ought not require a theological degree to comprehend. When one
human being claims ownership over another, we already have a word for that. It is called slavery. And no amount
of biblical vocabulary, appeals to divine design, or creative interpretations of headship will magically transform the
possession of another human being into servant leadership.
Feminism: Apparently, We Need a New Dictionary
Even so, historically, women were not fighting to become men. Why on earth would we? We were fighting for the right to exist as women without being treated as though our sex constituted some unfortunate deficiency in our humanity.
Which brings me to feminism as we know it today, and good heavens, what an extraordinary assortment of interpretations we've managed to accumulate under one little word. The definition appears to change depending on the platform, the particular woman claiming the title, or the self-appointed defender of patriarchy explaining to the rest of us what feminists supposedly believe. Between the increasingly elaborate labels and the rather imaginative portrayals circulated by those determined to make women's independence sound like an impending threat to civilization, I am not entirely convinced I could keep up with it all if I gave it my darnedest effort.
And so, what exactly is feminism?
Well, if you are asking me, I would have thought the answer was relatively straightforward. At its most basic, feminism advocates for equality between women and men. And when I say equality, I am not referring to sameness. I am referring to equal dignity, equal opportunity, equal treatment under the law, and equal compensation for equal work. That is the understanding of feminism I am working with, and I intend to stick with it. Anyone wishing to attach an additional seventeen ideological amendments to the definition is certainly welcome to do so, but I shall respectfully decline the invitation to accompany them down that particular rabbit hole.
I do not need to become a man to be considered equally human, nor should a man need to surrender
his masculinity to acknowledge that I am.
Now, what does either patriarchy or feminism have to do with the gospel of Christ? Well, as ideological platforms,
absolutely nothing. Not a blessed thing. And therein lies my point.
Somewhere between the creation of humanity and our rather creative interpretations of what it means to be the
body of Christ, we apparently decided that one body wasn't quite sufficient. So we divided it into camps, assigned
everyone a label, and proceeded to argue over which half was entitled to run the show. Being united in Christ was
all well and good, it seems, provided we could first establish who was in charge.
Genesis 3:16: When a Consequence Became a Commandment
The irony of Genesis 3:16 is certainly not lost on me. In the aftermath of the Fall, God announces the consequences of humanity's disobedience, including the rather unfortunate development that “he will rule over you,” alongside
the declaration that the woman's desire will be for her husband.
Now, I am not about to drag us into an exhaustive theological examination of the Hebrew nuances surrounding the word desire. That particular conversation could occupy an entire essay of its own, and I have no intention of adding another seventeen pages of linguistic debate to our itinerary today. Nevertheless, whatever interpretation we arrive at, the introduction of domination into the relationship between man and woman was hardly something to celebrate. And I would venture to suggest that women have had rather good reason to object to it ever since.
And this is where the absurdity really outdoes itself. God Himself announces this fractured relationship in the
context of humanity's separation from Him. It is part of the tragic consequences of the Fall, not a congratulatory
address to Adam on his promotion to management.
Yet here we are, thousands of years later, attempting to baptise the very consequences of sin in holy water, grant them an honorary doctorate in biblical authority, and convince everyone that God was not describing the damage at all. He was issuing a divine decree that the fractured relationship between male and female was to be faithfully preserved, preferably with the woman sufficiently grateful for her newly diminished standing.
I do wonder whether anyone has considered the rather inconvenient possibility that we are defending the very condition from which we profess to have been redeemed. But I suppose redemption is a minor detail when there is a hierarchy to preserve. God's intention for humanity was declared at creation. We need not rummage through centuries of cultural traditions, ecclesiastical arrangements, or somebody's rather enthusiastic interpretation of male authority to discover it. Genesis 1:26–28 introduces humanity as male and female, both created in the image of God, both blessed, and both entrusted with dominion over creation. There is no announcement of a hierarchy between them, no allocation of superior status based on reproductive anatomy, and certainly no indication that one was appointed to supervise the other's existence.
Now, if you intend to trumpet primogeniture as your rebuttal, I am afraid I shall have to disappoint you. I have already addressed that particular argument in my writing, and my book, The Tangent Series: Tearing the Veil, takes a considerably deeper dive into the subject for anyone interested in examining the rather extraordinary proposition that arriving first automatically qualifies someone to be in charge. This essay is not about primogeniture, and I refuse to spend the afternoon chasing Adam around the Garden to determine whether being fashioned from dust a little earlier entitled him to issue instructions to everyone who arrived after him.
What this essay is about, however, is the absolute monstrosity of a mess we have made of the Scriptures and the
division we have manufactured within the body of Christ. We have turned the very passages intended to inform
our understanding of God and our relationships with one another into ammunition for defending our respective ideologies.
The really astonishing part is that we seem perfectly content to keep pulling the trigger while professing allegiance
to the very Christ who called us to be one.
In Genesis 2:24, we are introduced to another rather inconvenient detail. Husband and wife are joined together as one flesh, a union that makes no mention of competing positions of authority, superior status, or the rather peculiar notion that one half of this union was appointed to govern the other. Those are God's words, not mine. Take it up with Him.
Nowhere, absolutely nowhere, does God announce that women have forfeited their equal standing as His image-bearers. Yet, judging by some of the arguments circulating in Christian circles, one might reasonably conclude that He had issued a subsequent amendment revoking women's original status and transferring their share of humanity's God-given authority to men. I must have missed that particular announcement.
In the beginning, male and female existed as counterparts, sharing in the goodness of God's creation, living together without shame, without the hostility that would follow the Fall, and enjoying unhindered fellowship with their Creator. They were naked, for heaven's sake, and neither had thought to appoint themselves the other's spiritual supervisor. It is rather remarkable how much authority we have managed to manufacture out of a relationship that God originally described as very good.
And when that unhindered fellowship with God was fractured, so too was the harmony between male and female. That is what God announced. That is what humanity has been suffering through ever since, along with the rather extensive catalogue of other consequences we inherited from the Fall. But the consequences of sin did not erase the image of God in either of His children. Humanity's relationship with its Creator was fractured, not its identity as His image-bearers.
We are living in the aftermath of a seismic rupture, yet, for reasons I find increasingly difficult to comprehend, certain proponents of patriarchy seem determined to convince us that the resulting fractures are evidence of God's
intended arrangement. And so, to those who incessantly declare that God established a hierarchy of authority
within marriage, I have a rather straightforward question. Where?
Where, precisely, does God announce that the woman, created equally in His image and joined to her husband as one
flesh, has been assigned a subordinate position beneath him? And please, spare me the lengthy detour through
cultural customs, assumptions about birth order, and the astonishing number of conclusions we have managed to
extract from what Scripture does not actually say.
How, exactly, does one divide one flesh?
Let me spell this out in elementary language, since we have managed to complicate something that ought not
require an advanced degree in theology to comprehend. With humanity's relationship to the Father now fractured,
His children began fighting like cats and dogs over who was entitled to the bigger piece of the pie.
Naturally, the bigger sibling decided he ought to have the whole bakery.
Now, I would imagine most parents would be rather pleased if their children could manage to coexist without one attempting to establish a dictatorship over the other. But convincing your sister that Dad secretly appointed you head of the household, particularly when He had already given you both an inheritance, is a rather creative interpretation of the family arrangements.
But alas, the serpent continues to strike at the woman's heel, and the hostility announced in the Garden has found itself a rather comfortable home among God's sons and daughters. One might even suspect that the enmity has acquired a few enthusiastic volunteers. Now, where have we seen this particular brand of hostility taking up residence? Oh, I know. Patriarchy!
Perhaps someone ought to write God a Pauline-style letter informing Him that the boys have developed a rather creative understanding of their inheritance and are refusing to share with their sisters. It seems a formal reprimand may be in order, although I suspect they would insist on reviewing the letter for theological accuracy before permitting anyone to deliver it.
Although, on second thought, perhaps we should reconsider the letter. I can already imagine someone extracting a
sentence from it, removing it from its context, and constructing an entire doctrine explaining why the girls were never
entitled to read the correspondence in the first place.
It would seem patriarchy is rather dead set on resurrecting the Fall, proudly defending the very fracture that Christ came to heal, while insisting that doing so is an act of faithfulness to Him. Meanwhile, reminding your brother that you are both children of the same Father is treated as an attempted hostile takeover of the family estate.
We are no longer discussing which sibling gets the bigger share of the inheritance. We are confronting the audacity of one sibling insisting that the other was never entitled to sit at the Father's table in the first place. Identity is what is at stake here, and patriarchy, it would seem, is still taking prisoners.
When the Father's Name Becomes the Alibi
Do we actually comprehend the magnitude of what is taking place here? We are talking about a human life. A daughter
who has been told that her Father, the very One who lovingly formed her in His image, deliberately created her to be less
than her brother. Not by accident, nor as a consequence of humanity's rebellion, but intentionally, as though her
inferior standing was part of His original intention for her existence. She is expected to believe that her subordinate
position was His idea, that the limitations imposed upon her are an expression of His love, and that she ought to be
eternally grateful for the privilege of knowing her place.
And what, precisely, do we imagine that does to a daughter's heart? Listen here, we are telling God's daughters that their Father deliberately created them with a deficiency in their very souls, an emptiness where His unconditional love
and affirmation ought to reside. That they were fashioned not as fully valued human beings with their own identities,
purposes, and relationship with Him, but as creatures bred for the benefit of another, their worth measured by
their usefulness and their obedience.
It is a grotesque picture, one that bears a disturbing resemblance to a breeding mill, where the value of a living creature is determined not by the sacredness of its existence but by what can be extracted from it. And to suggest that the Father Himself designed His daughters for such an existence, then expected them to thank Him for the privilege, is an accusation against His character that ought to horrify anyone claiming to know His heart.
What happens when a woman begins to believe that the Father she is commanded to love is the very One responsible for her humiliation? When she comes to understand her own existence as something He deliberately diminished, her gifts as something He deliberately restricted, and her voice as something He never particularly wanted to hear?
And notice how conveniently this arrangement reduces a grown woman to the status of a child, perpetually requiring supervision, correction, and permission from someone supposedly better equipped to determine what is good for her. She may possess decades of wisdom, experience, spiritual maturity, and an intimate relationship with her Creator, but none of that appears sufficient to earn her the right to be treated as a fully capable adult. Be seen, not heard. Know your place.
We are not merely talking about the subordination of women. We are talking about the systematic poisoning of a daughter's relationship with her Father, carried out by those who claim to speak on His behalf. And when that daughter begins to recoil from the God she has been taught to fear rather than trust, the very people responsible for distorting His character have the audacity to accuse her of bitterness, disobedience, and rebellion. And should she remain unconvinced by their rather generous interpretation of God's intentions for her existence, there is always the added incentive of eternal damnation, with a place in the fiery furnace of hell supposedly reserved for those who dare question the arrangement. Now, remind me, where have we encountered this hostility toward the woman before? Ah, yes. The Garden.
The serpent was told there would be enmity between him and the woman, and between his offspring and hers. And here we are, thousands of years later, watching certain proponents of patriarchy hoist the flag of enmity with all the enthusiasm of soldiers marching into battle, seemingly oblivious to whose banner they may be carrying.
I can almost picture the serpent reclining in an expensive leather armchair, a glass of Jack Daniel's on ice in one hand and a rather extravagant cigar in the other, watching the spectacle unfold with the smug satisfaction of someone who has discovered that he no longer needs to dirty his own hands. Why bother convincing a daughter to mistrust her Father when someone standing behind a pulpit will do it for him? Why spend another afternoon sowing division when the children have become so proficient at tearing one another apart, all while insisting that their Father specifically instructed them to do so?
He needn't even leave his chair. The enmity is being preached, defended, institutionalised, and passed down to the next generation, accompanied, rather extraordinarily, by the assurance that this is what God intended all along. And the most grotesque irony of it all is that those perpetuating the hostility may genuinely believe they are defending the Father's honour, while the daughters He created are being taught to despise the very nature of the God whose image they bear.
The serpent, it would seem, has played his hand well. Very, very well indeed.
We see the consequences of male entitlement and domination splashed across headlines with depressing regularity.
But some of their most disturbing expressions do not announce themselves with clenched fists or raised voices.
Sometimes they sing hymns on Sunday morning, greet you with a pleasant smile, and might even recite a Bible
verse for you, provided you have been sufficiently well behaved. And if you haven't, there is always a passage
conveniently available to remind you of your place.
And the voices are getting louder, the platforms are getting bigger, and the audiences are growing. The message
is being delivered with an increasingly brazen confidence that ought to alarm anyone who professes to
care about the integrity of the Gospel.
We have men publicly promoting the subordination of women, presenting their authority over their wives as a divine entitlement, and treating a woman's independence as though it were an infectious disease threatening to bring civilization to its knees. They are broadcasting these convictions, preaching them, publishing them, and encouraging other men to embrace them as evidence of biblical masculinity.
Meanwhile, the women subjected to these teachings are expected to receive them with gratitude, demonstrate their obedience with enthusiasm, and refrain from making everyone uncomfortable by mentioning the consequences. And should one of them have the nerve to object, there is always someone prepared to explain that her resistance is precisely why women ought not be trusted with authority in the first place.
What an extraordinarily efficient little arrangement. The accusation supplies its own evidence, the accused is denied the authority to challenge it, and the person making the accusation gets to congratulate himself on having defended the Word of God. All in a good day's work.
When the Guilty Become the Judges
And while we are discussing rebellion, I would dearly love to know how women managed to become its unofficial poster children when Adam himself provides us with such an impressive demonstration of the behaviour. Let us not forget
what Scripture actually says. According to 1 Timothy 2:14, Adam was not deceived. Romans 5:12 and 5:19 go so far as
to place the entrance of sin and the disobedience through which humanity suffered squarely at Adam's feet. And
when God confronted him in Genesis 3:12, did our courageous representative of biblical manhood stand before his
Creator and accept responsibility for his actions? Not on your life. He pointed at the woman. And for good
measure, he implicated God Himself for having given her to him.
Now, consider the breathtaking audacity of what we have done with that account. Adam has somehow become the preferred exhibit in the case for male spiritual authority, while Eve's deception has been paraded through centuries of theological argument as evidence that her entire sex requires male supervision. By this extraordinary line of reasoning, Adam's deliberate disobedience qualifies him for leadership, while Eve's deception disqualifies her descendants from exercising it. And then we have the gall to accuse women of rebellion when they question the arrangement.
I would suggest that before anyone delivers another sermon about the dangers of rebellious women, they might
consider the rather damning testimony of the man whose behaviour they seem so determined to excuse. And
given the seemingly endless procession of so-called “moral failings” among those entrusted with spiritual
authority, I do wonder how much more evidence we require before abandoning the rather extraordinary assumption
that being male is somehow a qualification for moral superiority.
Now, I am no psychologist, but there is something rather familiar about accusing another person of the very behaviour one is unwilling to confront in oneself. Projection, I believe, is the term. If you think this rather convenient reversal of responsibility was confined to the Garden, allow me to introduce you to one of its particularly ugly modern-day relatives: a phenomenon frequently described as reactive abuse, although I would argue that the terminology itself deserves to be hauled in for questioning. A woman can endure years of intimidation, humiliation, deception, manipulation, and coercive control, but the moment she finally raises her voice, confronts the behaviour, or establishes a boundary that inconveniences the person benefiting from her silence, suddenly we have ourselves a problem. It would seem we have become so proficient at assigning blame that we have forgotten the rather elementary distinction between causing harm and responding to it.
Not with the conduct that brought her to this point, mind you. That can wait. We have a woman's reaction to investigate.
And should she become angry, well, heaven help us. Now she is contentious, disrespectful, unsubmissive,
emotionally unstable, or, everyone's personal favourite, rebellious. And let us not forget the reviling wife, whose
refusal to quietly accommodate her husband's conduct can become the subject of yet another sermon on the
dangers of women who will not submit to male authority.
What an interesting contrast. We have an entire Christian literary genre devoted to every man's battle, complete with explanations of temptation, struggles, setbacks, and the need for grace. But when a woman begins responding to the consequences of those battles, her distress can be repackaged as evidence that she is the real problem. His behaviour is a battle to be understood. Hers is a character defect to be corrected. The original wrongdoing has barely managed to find its way into the conversation before her response has been hauled before the disciplinary committee.
And then, for the grand finale, we introduce the therapeutic language of mutual responsibility. Both parties contributed to the problem, we are told, and therefore both must examine their behaviour and accept responsibility for their respective contributions. What a wonderfully civilized conclusion, particularly for the person who has spent years creating the very conditions now being presented as a mutual disagreement.
If you mistreat someone long enough to provoke a reaction, you can eventually use that reaction as evidence that the two of you are equally responsible for the mess. And should a counsellor, pastor, or well-meaning mediator fail to distinguish between the pattern of abuse and the response to it, the very system entrusted with addressing the harm can become another instrument through which it is perpetuated.
We have now managed to make the injured person responsible not only for surviving the wrongdoing, but also for ensuring that her response does not inconvenience the person who caused it. The system protects itself, the harm continues, and everyone gets to congratulate themselves on having successfully addressed the conflict. How terribly convenient.
What's that I smell? Ah, yes. The serpent's cigar. The smoke is getting rather thick in here, and judging by the circumstances, I suspect he's taken up chain-smoking. The show has become far too entertaining to put the thing down.
God's Sons Are Not the Enemy
For those sharpening their pencils to accuse me of being a man-hating feminist, allow me to save you the trouble. I am not a misandrist, although I suspect that particular accusation will find its way into the conversation regardless of what I have written. A woman can spend an entire essay defending the dignity of human beings and still find herself accused of despising approximately half of them.
I love men. I love my husband. I love my father. I love my uncles. I love my cousins. I love my brothers in Christ. I have two absolutely wonderful sons-in-law, and I have grandsons whose futures matter enormously to me. I want these men,
and every other son of God, to know the true heart of their Father, to understand the sacredness of their own existence,
and to recognize the profound responsibility that comes with bearing His image.
I do not want a world without men. I do not want a church without men. I certainly do not want my grandsons growing up in a society that regards their masculinity as some unfortunate defect requiring an apology for their existence. And I will be equally uncompromising about any ideology that attempts to convince them that being male automatically makes them an oppressor, a threat, or an expendable member of humanity. What an appalling inheritance to hand a child.
Equally, I do not want these boys inheriting a version of Christianity that teaches them their worth is measured by how successfully they exercise authority over women. I do not want them confusing physical strength with moral superiority, mistaking entitlement for leadership, or believing that their sisters must become smaller in order for them to become men. What kind of Father would want His sons to derive their identity from the diminishment of His daughters?
And what does it say about the Gospel we are handing the next generation when we can no longer distinguish between the strength required to protect another human being and the cowardice involved in controlling one?
Patriarchy, when it becomes a system of male entitlement and domination, does not merely rob women of their identity. It robs men of something profoundly precious as well. It distorts their understanding of what it means to bear the image of God and risks alienating them from the very heart of the Father they profess to represent.
Imagine being taught that your God-given masculinity entitles you to something Christ Himself never demanded from
those He came to save. Imagine reaching adulthood convinced that the measure of your faithfulness is the degree to
which someone else submits to your authority, rather than the degree to which your own life reflects the character
of your Saviour. What a rather unfortunate misunderstanding of the very Saviour whose name you have been
invoking to defend the arrangement.
Men are not the enemy of women, and women are not the enemy of men. Neither is an inferior edition of humanity, nor was either created as an unnecessary accessory to the other's existence. We are not interchangeable, we are not disposable, and we most certainly are not competing for the right to bear an image that God has already bestowed upon us both.
I want my grandsons to grow into men whose strength is governed by love, whose convictions are informed by Scripture, whose courage is demonstrated through integrity, and whose understanding of masculinity bears some recognisable resemblance to the Christ they profess to follow. I want them to know their Father, not merely the version of Him that someone has constructed to secure a preferred arrangement of power. Teaching God's sons that their identity depends upon the subordination of His daughters does not elevate manhood. It makes their worth dependent upon the humiliation of another human being, and I cannot think of a more pitiful understanding of what it means to be a man.
One New Humanity. Apparently, That Was Too Much to Ask.
I have a question. When exactly did we decide that the Gospel of Jesus Christ needed to become a battleground upon which men and women were commissioned to fight one another? Are we in Rome? Is this the Colosseum? Have we assembled the gladiators, divided the spectators into opposing camps, and decided that the last one standing gets to claim victory on behalf of Christ? I would dearly love to know where Jesus issued the invitation to this particular blood sport.
Consider Ephesians 2:14–16. Paul is addressing the hostility that separated Jews and Gentiles, two groups whose religious, cultural, and historical divisions were hardly insignificant. And what does he announce? That Christ has made them one, destroyed the dividing wall of hostility, and reconciled them to God through the cross, creating in Himself one new humanity.
Yes, I am perfectly aware that Paul was addressing Jews and Gentiles rather than men and women, so we can dispense
with the theological dissertation on the historical context. In fact, I would encourage you to keep reading, because that
very context makes the argument for reconciliation all the more compelling. If Christ reconciled those who had
been separated by centuries of religious and cultural hostility, on what conceivable grounds do we imagine that
His body ought to cultivate hostility between its male and female members?
If that application still makes anyone uncomfortable, we can turn to Galatians 3:28, where Paul explicitly identifies male and female among those who are one in Christ Jesus. One in Christ does not mean identical, interchangeable, or stripped of our individuality, our distinctions, or the remarkable diversity with which our Creator endowed humanity. We do not cease to be male or female any more than we cease to possess the individual gifts, abilities, and personalities that make us who we are.
And then we have 1 Corinthians 12, where Paul describes the church as one body composed of many members, each belonging to the whole and contributing to its functioning. Paul does not describe a body in which certain members are permitted to declare the others unnecessary, nor does he suggest that one member's significance depends upon another's diminished standing. In fact, he goes to considerable lengths to explain precisely the opposite.
A Servant Washes Feet. He Does Not Whip People With the Towel.
Now, perhaps we ought to revisit the inconvenient example of Jesus Christ Himself, since He does happen to be the central figure in this entire conversation. I realise that bringing His actual conduct into a debate about Christian authority may prove somewhat disruptive to the established arrangements, but I would suggest that anyone claiming to represent Him ought to be prepared to have their understanding of authority measured against His example.
In Mark 10:42–45, Jesus addresses the matter of authority, drawing His disciples' attention to the rulers of the Gentiles who lord their power over those beneath them. Rather than offering His followers a few helpful suggestions for exercising that power more efficiently, He tells them, “Not so with you.” Not so with you.
I wonder how many sermons on biblical authority might require a substantial rewrite if we actually allowed those four words to govern our understanding of Christian leadership. Jesus continues by explaining that whoever wishes to become great must become a servant, and whoever wishes to be first must become a slave of all. He then points to Himself as the example, declaring that even the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give His life as a ransom for many.
And lest anyone imagine that these were merely pleasant philosophical sentiments, John 13 provides a striking
demonstration of what He meant. Jesus, fully aware of His identity and authority, gets up from the table, wraps a towel
around His waist, and begins washing His disciples' feet.
Now, consider the scene. The One whom Christians acknowledge as Lord, the very One through whom all things were made, assumes the position of a servant before the men who follow Him. He does not summon them to the front of the room to demonstrate their submission. He does not demand that they acknowledge His superior position before permitting them the privilege of receiving His attention. He kneels. And when He finishes, He instructs them to follow His example. One would think that such a demonstration might have settled a few questions about the nature of servant leadership, but judging by some of the arrangements being promoted in His name, the significance of the towel appears to have escaped us.
A servant leader washes feet. He does not whip people with the towel.
I cannot imagine how we have managed to turn such an unmistakable demonstration of humility into an arrangement in which one person enjoys the authority and the other is expected to supply the humility. And yet, I have encountered enough explanations of biblical headship to wonder whether we have developed an entirely new definition of servanthood, one in which the person supposedly doing the serving retains the final say, the superior position, and the God-given right to demand obedience from the person being served. What an extraordinary interpretation of washing someone's feet. Apparently, the towel has become a sceptre, and the basin has been replaced with a throne.
Philippians 2:3–8 offers little room for creative reinterpretation. Paul instructs believers to value others above themselves, to look to the interests of others, and to adopt the same mindset as Christ Jesus, who humbled Himself and became obedient to death, even death on a cross. Notice that these instructions are addressed to believers, not merely to women, wives, or some specially designated class of Christians whose biological characteristics qualify them for a lifetime membership in the servanthood department. All of us.
If we are going to invoke Ephesians 5 to defend our understanding of marriage, perhaps we ought to give the instructions directed toward husbands considerably more attention than they ordinarily receive. Husbands are commanded to love their wives as Christ loved the church and gave Himself up for her. Notice that He gave Himself up. He did not demand that the church sacrifice herself to preserve His comfort, protect His reputation, or satisfy His appetite for control. His love was demonstrated through the giving of Himself.
I am not suggesting that Christian leadership is devoid of responsibility or that every exercise of authority constitutes domination. Scripture speaks of leadership, accountability, teaching, and the obligations entrusted to those who
serve others. There is, however, a fundamental difference between accepting responsibility for another person's
welfare and claiming entitlement to govern their existence. One requires humility, integrity, sacrifice, and a willingness
to place the interests of others ahead of one's own. The other requires little more than a convincing explanation
of why someone else ought to obey you.
If your understanding of servant leadership requires another human being to surrender their autonomy, silence their objections, tolerate mistreatment, or relinquish their God-given dignity so that you can maintain your position of authority, you have fundamentally misunderstood what it means to serve. You are not washing their feet. You are standing on their neck, and calling it biblical leadership does not make the weight any less crushing.
Nor does this challenge apply exclusively to men. Women are not exempt from the command to serve, to love sacrificially,
to exercise humility, or to treat others with the dignity owed to those created in God's image. There is no special
dispensation permitting women to become domineering, contemptuous, or cruel merely because they have
experienced injustice, and no version of feminism earns an exemption from Christ's example. The Gospel does not
give us permission to become the very thing we condemn.
We keep asking who gets to be in charge, while Jesus keeps showing us what it means to serve. And if we still cannot recognise the difference, perhaps we ought to put down the towel before we hurt someone else with it. Those things smart, you know, especially when someone has mistaken them for an instrument of correction.
Everybody Wants the Throne. Nobody Wants the Cross.
So here we are, patriarchy and feminism, two words that have become sufficient grounds for launching an ideological war between people who were never intended to be enemies in the first place. I am perfectly capable of distinguishing between feminism's pursuit of equality and patriarchy's claims of authority, thank you very much. Fighting for equal rights is not equivalent to denying them, nor can the historical injustices suffered by women be conveniently erased by declaring that everybody has behaved badly and ought to shake hands.
Any ideology, regardless of its origins or the nobility of its stated intentions, becomes profoundly dangerous when it
begins treating another human being as an obstacle to its own supremacy. I do not particularly care whether the person
doing the diminishing is wearing a suit behind a pulpit or waving a banner in the name of liberation. If your
understanding of human dignity requires someone else's humanity to be reduced, I would suggest that your
definition is in desperate need of re-examination.
The Gospel of Jesus Christ is not an invitation to trade one form of domination for another. We have become so intoxicated with defending our respective positions that I fear we have lost sight of the staggering cost of the reconciliation we profess to celebrate. Why did our Saviour endure humiliation, suffering, and death upon a cross? Why do we gather on Sunday mornings to sing about His sacrifice, proclaim His resurrection, and celebrate the grace through which we have been reconciled to God, only to return to our respective corners and resume the business of tearing apart those He has called us to love?
Do we actually believe the Gospel we are preaching? Or have we become so accustomed to invoking the name of Jesus in defence of our preferred arrangements that we no longer recognise the contradiction between His example and our conduct?
I look at my grandsons and wonder what kind of Christianity they will inherit. Will they encounter a church that teaches them to recognise the image of God in every human being, or one that measures their significance by the degree of authority they can exercise over His daughters? Will they be taught that loving another human being means honouring their dignity, or will they inherit a version of love that confuses devotion with possession?
And what of our daughters? Will they be raised knowing that their Father created them with dignity, purpose, intelligence, and gifts worthy of being exercised in His service? Or will they continue to be handed a theological explanation for why their existence must be negotiated through someone else's authority? I want better for both.
I do not want a world in which women replace men, nor one in which men are elevated at the expense of women. I want a church that has enough reverence for its Creator to stop treating His image-bearers as opposing teams in a competition nobody was commissioned to organise. The impact matters. The people bearing that impact matter. And the integrity of the Gospel we claim to represent matters.
We are not discussing some inconsequential difference of opinion that can be neatly filed away under the
heading of theological disagreement. We are discussing human lives, spiritual identities, damaged relationships, distorted
understandings of God, and generations being taught what it supposedly means to follow Christ. I am increasingly
unwilling to watch that damage be dismissed as the unfortunate but necessary cost of preserving someone's preferred interpretation of biblical authority.
Christ called us to love one another, to serve one another, and to recognize that whatever we do to the least of those among us matters to Him. He did not invite us to construct competing kingdoms in His name, nor did He commission His followers to determine which half of humanity was entitled to occupy the throne. He called us to take up our crosses and follow Him, yet we have become remarkably enthusiastic about defending the authority we believe belongs to us while demonstrating considerably less enthusiasm for the sacrifice He requires of us.
Everybody wants the throne. Nobody wants the cross.
Does your version of patriarchy or feminism uphold the sacredness of the human life God created in His image, or have you become so determined to defend your position that you are prepared to diminish the very people Christ died to redeem?