R J BURTON
  • Home
  • About The Author
  • Bookstore
    • Tearing The Veil
    • Blaming GOD A Victim's Journey
  • Written Works
    • Poetry and Verse >
      • Trauma Tax Poem
      • Beyond The Headlines
      • Faithful Sinner
    • Essays >
      • What Happens After it Happens
      • Patriarchy vs. Feminism
      • Knowledge Is Power
    • Scripture Under Investigation >
      • Does your husband own your body?
      • Does God Forget Your Sins?
      • Does God Promise He Won't Give You More Than You Can Handle?
      • Does God Punish Children for Their Parents' Sins?
    • Christianese Translated >
      • Detouring
      • False Teachers
      • Lust
      • Repentance
      • Primogeniture
      • Enmity
      • Slander
      • Hypocrisy
      • Accountability
      • Reactive Abuse
      • Boundaries
    • The Tangent Series >
      • Speak Here NOT There
      • Forgiveness
      • Leadership
      • The Victim's Act
      • Covenantal Marriage
      • Patriarchy Survived the Law
      • The Victim Tax
      • Polygamy
      • Boys' Club
      • Restitution
    • Gracepoint Q & A >
      • Q1
      • Q2
      • Q3
      • Q4
      • Q5
      • Q6
  • Reviews
  • Contact

Knowledge Is Power

Unless It Proves You Wrong
Submitted by: Darla Burton

There is this little something called pride that has a rather peculiar habit of wedging itself between what we think we
know and what we might actually learn, and once it has made itself comfortable, getting it to budge can be about
as easy as convincing a Newfoundland mosquito that you’ve already donated enough blood.

Now, I’m pretty sure none of my readers have the faintest idea what I’m talking about, but on the off chance
something has tickled your ears, I’ll continue down this little trail for just a moment.
​
Remember when we were youngsters and were absolutely convinced that we knew everything? Heaven help the
poor soul who dared suggest otherwise. In fact, the sheer audacity of someone attempting to override our near-perfect understanding of the world generally served no greater purpose than to make us dig our heels in a little further.

Sometimes, despite the well-intentioned advice of our elders, who insisted that their way was the right way, we
remained steadfastly committed to our own rather remarkable intelligence. And when we were presented
with that familiar ultimatum, it’s my way or the highway, well, some of us were only too happy to take the highway.
Of course, Hitchhiking, no less. I mean, it wasn’t like that all-knowing ability transferred into anything tangible like
hands on a steering wheel.

Now, if you’ve ever hitchhiked, you’ll know that you’re rolling the dice. You might get lucky and find yourself picked up by
some kindhearted soul who genuinely wants to help you along your way. Of course, there is also the other possibility,
but I’ll leave that to your imagination because this post is not intended to be a public safety announcement. Although,
come to think of it, perhaps it ought to be.

And considering that Matt Walsh has recently taken it upon himself to share his rather unflattering opinions
about the Newfoundland accent, following the filming of  Below in my beautiful home province, it would seem my
snark is a little more alive than usual these days. But I digress.

Stupid. Solomon Said It, Not Me.
When I think about the necessity of acquiring knowledge and wisdom, particularly from the perspective of faith,
there are several passages of Scripture that immediately come to mind.

We have 1 Thessalonians 5:21, which instructs us to test all things and hold fast to what is good. Proverbs 18:15
tells us that the heart of the discerning acquires knowledge, while Proverbs 4:7 encourages us to get
wisdom and, with all our getting, to get understanding. Proverbs 19:2 warns against desire without knowledge,
Proverbs 1:5 tells us that the wise will increase in learning, and Proverbs 2:3–6 goes so far as to compare seeking
wisdom and understanding to searching for hidden treasure.

Goodness gracious, the writer of Proverbs certainly had a lot to say about smartness. Although, it would seem he
reserved some of his more colourful commentary for those who were rather generously endowed with opinions
and a suspicious shortage of knowledge.

While we are at it, we may as well take a little detour with the writer (traditionally attributed primarily to King
Solomon) through Proverbs 12:1: “Whoever loves instruction loves knowledge, but he who hates correction
is stupid” (NKJV). Now, I’ve deliberately chosen the New King James Version here, which isn’t generally my first port of call,
but that final word is rather difficult to improve upon.

Stupid.

I think in Newfie slang, that would translate rather nicely into, “Stun as me arse.” And we’re not talking about some
poor unfortunate soul who hasn’t had the benefit of an education, mind you, but rather someone who has been
confronted with knowledge yet possesses the remarkable determination to remain completely unaffected by it.

Stupid.

Sorry. I just had to write it again. I taught my girls never to use that word and here I am reciting it twice. Well, there’s
a word that leaves precious little room for a committee of biblical manhood experts to convene, draft an official
statement, and explain why Solomon couldn’t possibly have meant what he said. But then again, I suppose that’s
what happens when a few gentlemen appoint themselves custodians of divine design and decide that Scripture could
benefit from a little administrative assistance. Although, I suppose stranger things have happened in Danvers.

Mind you, we do see things more clearly through “isms,” don’t we? Hey, I’ve even been guilty of creating some of
my own from time to time. In my defense, however, I do try to make the absurdity obvious. Of course, I seriously
doubt the Church, in all its collective wisdom, would ever embrace a different gospel (Paul’s terminology, not
mine), divide Christ’s body into divinely sanctioned superiors and subordinates, and then spend several
decades defending the arrangement as biblical faithfulness. Good heavens, imagine the theological
entitlement. Surely, someone, somewhere, anywhere, would have noticed the rather inconvenient irony of
dividing a body Christ had already made one.

Introducing the Stubbornly Unteachable Version
And speaking of theological entitlement, I thought it might be rather entertaining to demonstrate what happens
when our opinions become so precious that even Solomon’s rather unambiguous warning about correction
is no longer permitted to interfere with them. And just so we’re clear, we snoopy women do have an unfortunate
habit of asking questions, particularly when someone insists we ought not to.

So, for argument’s sake, let’s take Proverbs 12:1, turn it on its head (taking a little inspiration from the apostle
Paul, who wasn’t exactly renowned for leaving comfortable religious assumptions undisturbed), and
introduce a rather unconventional translation. We’ll call it the SUV.

The Stubbornly Unteachable Version.

Now, when you hear SUV, perhaps you’re picturing one of those oversized vehicles with enough room to
accommodate an entire caravan of opinions. Plenty of space for thoughts to bounce around, provided none of
them are permitted to settle anywhere that might interfere with the driver’s predetermined destination.

And so, without further ado, I present: Proverbs 12:1, According to the Stubbornly Unteachable (SUV)

An entirely fictional rendering of what happens when pride gets hold of biblical interpretation.

“Whoever loves his own opinion despises correction, and whoever acquires knowledge contrary to his beliefs
shall promptly reject it, lest he suffer the great indignity of having to admit he was wrong.”


There. I think that rather nicely captures the spirit of the thing. And naturally, I’ve used masculine pronouns throughout.
Far be it from me to interfere with a long- standing tradition of allowing the masculine to speak for everyone.

Take, for example, Paul’s use of the Greek adelphoi, a term that can refer collectively to brothers and sisters. Yet
how often have English readers encountered brothers or brethren and been left to assume that the sisters were
merely hanging around somewhere in the background, perhaps preparing refreshments while the important
theological discussions took place?

And wouldn’t you know it, even when the Father has made it abundantly clear that the inheritance belongs to
His sons and daughters alike, some of our brothers seem rather determined to help themselves to the lion’s share. I
suppose old habits die hard, particularly when there’s an entitlement to preserve. Although, for the life of me, I
don’t recall anyone inviting Jacob to dinner.

Now, in my little SUV translation, the inheritance being so vigorously defended is the privilege of remaining
stubbornly, spectacularly, and quite possibly willfully wrong. And judging by the queue, business is booming. Of course,
the gentlemen haven’t cornered the market on this particular inheritance. Women are perfectly capable
of being stubbornly unteachable too. Pride is an equal- opportunity offender, even if some of our theological
traditions have been rather selective about distributing authority.

In God We Trust. Terms and Conditions Apply.
Which brings me to the point of this rather lengthy excursion. Throughout our lives, we are taught certain
things, and those things gradually become the framework through which we understand the world. We inherit
opinions, assumptions, traditions, and interpretations, often long before we possess the knowledge necessary
to examine them. I mean, here I am in my fifties, only now coming to terms with just how much theological
bologna I’ve been taught over the years, much of it presented with such conviction that questioning it was
considered a greater offence than getting it wrong in the first place. Scripture, I would argue, is no exception when
it comes to interpretations we’ve inherited.

For generations, much of Scripture has been taught through a predominantly masculine interpretive lens. And
while the grammatical structures of Hebrew and Greek certainly deserve careful consideration, grammatical
masculinity and masculine bias are not the same thing. Through that lens, it would appear, the former has too
often been used to justify the latter, and the result has been a rather impressive exercise in masculinisation.

Suppose you’ve spent your entire life believing a particular interpretation of Scripture because it was
handed to you as unquestionable truth. You’ve heard it preached from the pulpit, reinforced in your home,
defended in theological discussions, and perhaps even warned that questioning it amounts to questioning God
Himself. Then, one day, you begin to study. Not to confirm what you already believe, but to understand what
is actually written. That is what spiritual maturity asks of us. You examine the language, the context, the history,
the audience, and the broader testimony of Scripture. You begin asking questions that perhaps nobody
encouraged you to ask before.

And then, just when you thought you had God all figured out, along comes some rather inconvenient knowledge
suggesting that the character of God you’ve spent years defending might bear a suspicious resemblance to the
people who taught you about Him. Suddenly, the consequences of humanity’s rebellion begin looking
remarkably different from God’s original design, and that divinely sanctioned hierarchy you’ve so faithfully
defended starts resembling the very fractured relationship Christ came to redeem. Now, wouldn’t that
be an unfortunate discovery? All those years defending what you believed to be God’s intentions, only to discover
you may have been defending the consequences of sin with considerably more enthusiasm than the redemption
Christ came to accomplish. And to make matters worse, you might actually have to admit you were wrong.
Whatever would the theological establishment do with such a scandal?

Theological Certainty: No Refunds, No Returns.
But now we have a problem, don’t we? Perhaps another carefully curated statement is in order. Although, I do
wonder what would happen if a committee of women took it upon themselves to convene and draft an official
statement explaining God’s divine design for men. I suspect we’d barely have the chairs pulled out before the
patriarchal establishment caught a whiff of what was happening and called in the Air Force. One can only
imagine the theological emergency of women appointing themselves the very authority men have so generously
bestowed upon themselves.

We could, of course, allow new knowledge to refine our understanding, but where’s the fun in that when we can
dig our heels in, reach for the nearest theological defence, and insist that what we’ve always believed must be
correct for the remarkably compelling reason that we’ve always believed it? And if anyone should dare present
evidence to the contrary, well, we can simply dismiss them as rebellious, deceived, or dangerously lacking in
submission to the appropriate authorities. Problem solved. As I always say, “The system feeds the system.”

No need to examine the evidence, reconsider the interpretation, or entertain the rather horrifying possibility
that our understanding wasn’t quite as infallible as we’d imagined. Seriously, why trouble ourselves with solid food
when we’ve become so remarkably comfortable with milk?

The SUV has plenty of fuel left in the tank, and we’re certainly not stopping for directions. Pride, however, is a
rather expensive travelling companion. It has an enormous stake in preserving our certainty, particularly
when our identity, reputation, authority, or sense of belonging has become attached to what we believe.

I rather suspect that’s why changing our minds can feel considerably more threatening than discovering
something new. Acquiring knowledge is one thing. Allowing that knowledge to correct us is quite another.
The latter tends to require a certain uncomfortable encounter with our own ego, and there’s no theological
Band-Aid quite large enough to cover that particular ouch. Best leave it alone to fester.

And there lies the contradiction. Scripture calls us to accept correction, yet we can become so fiercely committed
to defending our interpretation that we end up resisting the very instruction we claim to honour. I do wonder whether
anyone has considered that defending an interpretation and defending God are not necessarily the same thing. The
greater concern, if I may be so bold, is whether what we are so determined to defend actually reflects His character.

Being Right. At Whose Expense?
Which brings me to the much larger question. What exactly are we sacrificing for the privilege of being right?
From the perspective of faith, the stakes extend far beyond winning an argument or preserving a theological
position. They concern our relationship with the Father, our willingness to be corrected by Him, and the integrity
with which we represent His character to others.

We are talking about the impact our beliefs have on the people who must live beneath them, particularly when
those beliefs are used to justify authority, diminish another person’s dignity, or defend conditions from which
we profess to have been redeemed. The question is whether our commitment is genuinely to truth or simply to
the comfort of what we have always believed.

If God brings us to a place where we recognise that our understanding has been incomplete, are we willing to
humble ourselves and reconsider it? Or will we continue down the proverbial highway, clutching our theological
luggage, insisting that the road must be right because we’ve been travelling it for so long?

I am reminded of something I wrote in my first book, Blaming GOD – A Victim’s Journey, and I find it rather
interesting that, years later, I am returning to the very same concern, albeit from a slightly different direction.

“Whether we think we are better or we think we are worse—we are prideful. True humility is knowing and
believing who you are in Christ. It is accepting He is enough and developing a humble, loving relationship with
Him that produces a life reflecting His teachings. Pride and selfishness pull us away from the character of faith
and make us susceptible to the misleading allure of self- made religions.”

And there it is right there on the page. Self-made religions. Isn’t that a rather inconvenient possibility to
consider, particularly when we’ve mistaken defending our own beliefs for defending God? Pride does not always
announce itself through arrogance or an inflated sense of superiority, although goodness knows, some of that
superiority has been yelling rather loudly. Sometimes it hides beneath insecurity, defensiveness, fear, or an
unwillingness to admit that what we once believed may not have been true.

Humility, on the other hand, requires us to recognise that we are neither the authors of truth nor the final authorities
on its interpretation. And if admitting we were wrong is the price of growing in wisdom, perhaps the greater indignity
would be refusing to pay it. Let’s face it, what good is getting wisdom if we’re too proud to let it teach us anything?

Which brings me right back to Proverbs 12:1.

“Whoever loves instruction loves knowledge, but he who hates correction is stupid.”

Solomon certainly wasn’t inclined to mince words, was he? And I do suspect he wasn’t referring exclusively to the
correction we’re so generously prepared to administer to everyone else. I must say, judging by some of the names
women are called in social media comment sections for daring to question a man’s interpretation of Scripture, I
suspect Solomon’s warning about correction has been mistaken for permission to administer a verbal flogging.

There is no particular virtue in remaining steadfastly committed to an opinion simply because it was the first
one we acquired. Knowledge ought to inform our understanding, wisdom ought to refine it, and humility
ought to permit us to change it when what we have learned no longer supports what we once believed.

God is not obligated to validate our understanding simply because we’ve spent a lifetime defending it. And I do find
it rather peculiar that we can profess to be led by the Holy Spirit while remaining so fiercely opposed to the possibility
that He might have something to teach us. We are quite happy to acknowledge that Scripture is God-breathed,
provided, of course, that nobody suggests our interpretation of it might be suffering from a shortage of oxygen.

What exactly are we protecting here? The integrity of God’s Word, or the rather impressive collection of
opinions we’ve accumulated in His name?

I am particularly fascinated by the confidence required to appoint oneself an authority on divine design, draft a
statement explaining what God intended, and then regard anyone who questions that statement as a threat to
biblical faithfulness. For the love of Peter, imagine the sheer audacity of a woman opening her own Bible and
expecting God to speak to her without first obtaining permission from the gentlemen who have so graciously
appointed themselves His interpreters.

And Matt Walsh, b’y, I wouldn’t be too quick to dismiss a woman on account of her Newfoundland accent. Some of
us may sound a little different, but we’re perfectly capable of recognising when someone is talking through his arse.

After all, Solomon had a word for those who despise correction.
​
And I believe we’ve already established what that word was.
Follow me on Facebook and Instagram Below!
[email protected]
  • Home
  • About The Author
  • Bookstore
    • Tearing The Veil
    • Blaming GOD A Victim's Journey
  • Written Works
    • Poetry and Verse >
      • Trauma Tax Poem
      • Beyond The Headlines
      • Faithful Sinner
    • Essays >
      • What Happens After it Happens
      • Patriarchy vs. Feminism
      • Knowledge Is Power
    • Scripture Under Investigation >
      • Does your husband own your body?
      • Does God Forget Your Sins?
      • Does God Promise He Won't Give You More Than You Can Handle?
      • Does God Punish Children for Their Parents' Sins?
    • Christianese Translated >
      • Detouring
      • False Teachers
      • Lust
      • Repentance
      • Primogeniture
      • Enmity
      • Slander
      • Hypocrisy
      • Accountability
      • Reactive Abuse
      • Boundaries
    • The Tangent Series >
      • Speak Here NOT There
      • Forgiveness
      • Leadership
      • The Victim's Act
      • Covenantal Marriage
      • Patriarchy Survived the Law
      • The Victim Tax
      • Polygamy
      • Boys' Club
      • Restitution
    • Gracepoint Q & A >
      • Q1
      • Q2
      • Q3
      • Q4
      • Q5
      • Q6
  • Reviews
  • Contact